HAYIDION The Prizmah Journal

A Reform Approach to Tanakh Education

by Eric Petersiel Issue: Teaching Tanakh

The author shows the way that a Reform school approaches Tanakh, informed with resources from ancient Near Eastern scholarship and comparative mythology as well as within Jewish tradition.

It is somewhat paradoxical that I developed a Reform outlook on Torah from an Orthodox rabbi, but I was not the only one who found Rabbi B. Barry Levy’s introduction to Jewish studies at McGill University an eye-opener. The only text for the course was a Tanakh, in any form, and the required reading was all 24 books of the Hebrew Bible. While I was familiar with Torah and certainly the major stories of Shoftim and Yehoshua, this class introduced me to the depth of narrative and human insight in the stories of the kings, the minor prophets, and the wisdom literature. The lessons driven home by Professor Levy continue to influence my thinking on how I understand Torah and have shaped the way holy text is taught at The Leo Baeck Day School in Toronto.

Leo Baeck, the only Reform day school in Canada, embraces an international mindset centered in critical thinking and was authorized last year as the only Jewish International Baccalaureate World School in North America. Inherent in this educational philosophy is the belief that multiple perspectives best enable us to deeply investigate any problem, an approach mirrored in the traditional Jewish dialectic of biblical interpretation. Two key messages which formed the basis of Professor Levy’s teachings have helped to shape the way Leo Baeck approaches the study of Tanakh.

The Hebrew Bible was not written in a vacuum

In addition to a close reading of Tanakh, Rabbi Levy helped me to view biblical text and stories within a historical context. I developed a love of archaeology, studied ancient Near Eastern cultures and a range of Semitic languages, including Aramaic and Syriac. And just as he presented Tanakh to eager undergraduate students, we too teach our students to see the parallels between the holy text and the historical world around it. A familiarity with Hammurabi’s Code and the Epic of Gilgamesh are more than useful in understanding the legal and literary context of Tanakh, a message we teach from a young age. The innovative nature of the legal and moral code presented in Torah, especially against the background of the day, is one aspect of the text which we must highlight for children. That it speaks so deeply to the formation of the morality code by which we live today also highlights the potential divine inspiration.

These few examples applied to Tanakh help us create a similar process for the study of all texts, ancient or modern. It is not dissimilar from the way our students study To Kill a Mockingbird together with students at The Davis Academy in Atlanta. Understanding the factors which influence how we read the context of any literature is a vital element for exploring the bias we put into our reading of a text; our Canadian students compare their understanding of this seminal work exploring racial inequality in the South with the understanding of their peers from Atlanta.

Armed with a basic understanding of the world which surrounds the Ancient Israel presented through Tanakh, students can explore similar world literature in other cultures through the same lens. For example, students study a variety of examples of flood myths. A critical investigator of Torah cannot help but acknowledge that the flood story (or stories) presented in Bereishit is stunningly similar to those in a myriad of other cultures. Students must come to terms with how it is even possible that such similarity exists. They are able to hypothesize, just as scholars do, that perhaps this is evidence of the existence of a great flood, and we teach them other theories to help explain the phenomena.

The Bible is not a history book

Perhaps the greatest struggle we have in interpreting Torah in the modern world is our need for it to fit into the patterns of contemporary historiography. Using Joel Lurie Grishaver’s classic material from Learning Torah to engage students at their level, Grade 7 students read the first two chapters of Bereishit side by side and compare the two stories of creation described there. They are often struck by the contradictions which must be “explained away” in order to make Bereishit read as a singular historical account. The most basic example is the presence of water and then the sudden absence of it in the second chapter of Bereishit, which provides an opportunity to explore the reason for the existence of Torah, and how we find meaning in it. Professor Levy first opened the possibility for us that even the Masoretes had a variety of Torah texts before them from which to winnow a definitive scribal tradition, evident as far back as the disagreement in Kiddushin 30a as to which letter is the middle in the Torah (which simple counting demonstrates is far off the center of our accepted Masoretic text today).

Once students can accept that Tanakh is not linear or perfect, that it possibly uses parable as a literary technique and that in the ancient world two separate and contradictory stories of creation could exist side by side, they are forced to search more deeply for their own meaning in the text. For me this epiphany is the most satisfying moment in the study of Jewish text. Freed from the shackles of having to view Tanakh as a linear history of human existence and the Jewish people, the door is now open for each child, as it was for me, to move from a superficial acceptance of the historicity of Torah to a more mature study of the nuance and divinity in a text rife with apparent contradiction.

Armed with a modern approach to the study of Torah, our students must grapple with mature insights into the text and its impact on our Jewish lives. Rabbi Elyse Goldstein teaches that the average adult Jew’s understanding of God is stunted and immature, as many have stopped considering theology seriously after celebrating Bar Mitzvah. If we similarly held onto pre-teen views of love, of adolescent views of sex, how stunted would we be as adults?

Our job as educators is to equip students with the skills and background necessary to continue the quest into a mature understanding of the mysteries unveiled through the study of Jewish text, the most notable mystery being the role of God in our lives and our own Jewish identities. If straightforward logic demonstrates that Torah cannot be a trusted historical account, then what is left for us, for our students, to cling to? Giving students the tools to investigate such complex existential questions provides one of the core elements of our educational experience and ensures that our students can truly be lifelong learners of the most difficult subject matter.

In the introduction to his Torah commentary, Rabbi W. Gunther Plaut says, “The Torah is a book about humanity’s understanding of and experience with God…While individual authors had a hand in its composition, God’s voice may be heard through theirs if we listen with open minds.” Having compared in depth various flood stories, students explore the theory that in fact the story of Noah is a composite of two original tales woven together. Pulling apart the contradictory details (did the flood last 40 days or 150 days?) gives students a realistic understanding of how to understand the structure of Torah, but it opens for them this most difficult question of all, that of the authorship and accuracy of Torah.

Perhaps in contrast to the majority of Jewish day schools in North America, we teach our students the basis of the Documentary Hypothesis as a tool for understanding Torah, to grapple with the possibility that our Torah is not a unified text, but in fact drawn from a variety of sources to tell the story of our people. Just as we teach students the critical skills to discern the bias of the author of a website, we teach them to look into the rationale which may have influenced the various sources. Understanding the human need for order inherent in the first chapter of Bereishit brings us closer to the text as answering deep-seated human questions, in our current era just as in the ancient world. Against this backdrop we can move from a superficial understanding of the role of God in our lives and in the history of the Jewish people to a deeper, more complex struggle that we all have, and must equip our next generation to consider as well.&daims;

Eric Petersiel is the head of school at the Leo Baeck Day School in Toronto, Ontario. He can be reached at epetersiel@leobaeck.ca.

Go To the Next Article

Staying Abraham’s Hand: On...

Many passages in Tanakh present considerable challenges to the reader for a host of reasons. This article suggests......


Penalaran ini berawal dari peristiwa yang merupakan sebab, kemudian sampai pada kesimpulan sebagai akibatnya. Polanya adalah A mengakibatkan B. Contoh:Supplier sch 40 Supplier sch 40 Supplier Plat kapal besi baja bki krakatau steel Supplier besi Pipa sch 80 baja jual hp asus murah jual hp asus murah Supplier besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan ala jepang Pabrik Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 40 Toko Besi Unp Baja Supplier besi wf jual laptop asus jual laptop asus jual laptop asus murah jual laptop asus murah www.jualbesibajamurah.com Toko sch 40 Toko sch 40 Supplier besi siku Toko besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi wf baja undangan pernikahan islami Pabrik Pipa Besi Hitam Medium Jual Besi Unp Baja Toko besi wf Distributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos polos ulir Agen sch 40 Agen sch 40 Supplier pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 Agen besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi unp undangan pernikahan ada fotonya Pabrik Besi Wf Harga Besi Unp Baja Agen besi wf Distributor besi beton sii Pabrik sch 40 Pabrik sch 40 Supplier Plat besi Pabrik besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi siku undangan pernikahan simple undangan pernikahan ala india Pabrik Besi H beam Pabrik Besi Unp Baja Pabrik besi wf Distributor besi beton psi Ulir Polos Distributor besi Pipa sch 80 baja Distributor besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi h beam Distributor Plat Bordes Supplier Plat besi plat kapal undangan pernikahan Pabrik Besi Beton Distributor Besi Cnp Baja Distributor Besi Beton Distributor besi beton perwira Harga besi Pipa sch 80 baja Harga besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi wf Harga Plat Bordes Supplier besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan simple www.sentrabesibaja.com Supplier Besi Cnp Baja Harga Besi Beton Distributor besi beton PAS Jual besi Pipa sch 80 baja Jual besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier wiremesh Jual Plat Bordes Supplier besi cnp undangan pernikahan bermanfaat Distributor Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam Agen Besi Cnp Baja Jual Besi Beton Distributor besi beton master steel ms Supplier besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi unp Supplier Plat Bordes www.gudangbesibaja.com undangan pernikahan islami Distributor Bondek Cor Toko Besi Cnp Baja Supplier Besi Beton Distributor besi beton ksty Toko besi Pipa sch 80 baja Toko besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi cnp Toko Plat Bordes Pabrik besi Wf Baja undangan pernikahan amplop surat Distributor Atap Spandek Sni Jual Besi Cnp Baja Toko Besi Beton Distributor besi beton krakatau steel Agen besi Pipa sch 80 baja Agen besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi hollow Agen Plat Bordes Pabrik bondek undangan pernikahan bentuk dompet Distributor Plat Bordes Kembang Harga Besi Cnp Baja Agen Besi Beton Distributor besi beton jcac Pabrik besi Pipa sch 80 baja Pabrik besi Pipa sch 80 baja Supplier besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Pabrik Plat Bordes Pabrik wiremesh undangan pernikahan chinese Distributor Plat Besi Hitam Pabrik Besi Cnp Baja Pabrik Besi Beton Distributor besi beton interworld steel is Distributor Plat Bordes Distributor Plat Bordes ironsteelcenter.com Distributor Wiremesh Besi Pabrik pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan lucu Distributor Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Distributor Besi Hollow Baja Distributor besi hollow Distributor besi beton gunung garuda Harga Plat Bordes Harga Plat Bordes Pabrik stainless steel Harga Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi hollow undangan pernikahan bagus Distributor Jual Besi Siku Baja Supplier Besi Hollow Baja Harga besi hollow Distributor besi beton delcoprima Jual Plat Bordes Jual Plat Bordes Pabrik atap spandek Jual Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam Distributor Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal Agen Besi Hollow Baja Jual besi hollow Distributor besi beton cakra steel cs Supplier Plat Bordes Supplier Plat Bordes Pabrik baja ringan Supplier Wiremesh Besi Pabrik besi wf baja undangan pernikahan contoh Distributor Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Toko Besi Hollow Baja link6 

0 users have voted.

I am to an exceptional degree enthusiastic that I contorted up discernibly OK with the information gave, this is an astoundingly hypnotizing and key article,  ​godaddy $1/monthly hosting I will ask about it to my frill.

0 users have voted.

OBAT STROKE yang sangat ampuh untuk penyakit stroke bisamenggunakan OBAT STROKE herbal.  OBAT STROKE yang terbuat dari herbal sangat ampuh dala mengatasi penyakit stroke, karena OBAT STROKE herbal terbuat dari ramuan herbal terpercaya sehingga menjadikan OBAT STROKE herbal menjadi salah satu OBAT STROKE yang sangat bagus dan juga OBAT STROKE yang ampuh. Banyak manfaat yang terkandung dalam OBAT STROKE tradisional, yaitu OBAT STROKE tradisional  tidak memiliki efek samping, OBAT STROKE tradisional 100% Alami OBAT STROKE

0 users have voted.

OBAT ASAM URAT yang ampuh mengatasi asam urat yaitu OBAT ASAM URAT yang terbuat dari herbal. Dengan OBAT ASAM URAT herbal,penyakit asamurat akut akan segera sembuh kaena OBAT ASAM URAT herbal terbuat dari ramuan treadisional yang diektrak sehingga menghasilkan OBAT ASAM URAT. OBAT ASAM URAT yang mujarab dalam mengatasi asam urat, serta keunggulan dari OBAT ASAM URAT alami ini mampu mengobati asam urat tanpa efek samping.itu adalah keunggulan dari OBAT ASAM URAT yang terbuat dari tradisional alami OBAT ASAM URAT ampuh. Semoga info mengenai OBAT ASAM URAT dapat bermanfaat bagi penderita yang sedang mencari OBAT ASAM URAT herbal alami OBAT ASAM URAT

0 users have voted.

Teaching Tanakh

Tanakh (the Jewish Bible, Prophets and Writings) is the cornerstone of Jewish tradition; but how do we take our most ancient text and make it come alive for contemporary Jews? Read how educators deploy an array of methodologies and pedagogies to unlock the treasures of the Tanakh for today’s students.

Click here to download the PDF and printer friendly version of this issue of HaYidion